Food Storage Taste Test

UPDATE:  Daily Bread called today and said they would send me a different sample to try.  That they were aware of the wateriness of the lasagna and have since revised it to only add 3/4 cup of water instead of a full cup and then to let it sit 10-15 minutes instead of 8-9.

This will be a different kind of post from the normal ones.  Our church has asked us to prepare ourselves in the event of disasters, hardships, inclement weather circumstances, etc.  Part of that preparation is making sure we have a one year food supply for all members of our family.

In the past couple of years new companies have come out with products that are supposed to be ready made meals all you do is add boiling water and you have a meal.  The nice thing that they claim, is that these meals unopened will last on your shelf for 25 years!  Now to me, that's the easiest way to do food storage.  Buy it once (instead of rotating through it as the expiration dates on food come up) and forget about it for 25 years.  But if you need it, it's there and you just add water.

Now I'm skeptical about anything that is that easy.  Wouldn't you be?  This is what your family would have to live on if need be.  Will it taste good?  Will my kids eat it (that's the real question)?  Will it really last 25 years?

Two of the companies that I'm talking about are Daily Bread and The Wise Company.  I'm sure there are more companies that offer this service but these are the two I received samples from.  Both websites will gladly send you a free sample of a meal to try it out for yourself.

Here are the two samples I received.  Just as a side note, I didn't doctor up these pictures like I normally would in photoshop because I wanted you to see what they really look like to decide for yourself.

Each sample was a pasta of some sort.  Daily Bread was a Lasagna with Meat Sauce and Wise Company was Pasta Alfredo.  Both samples were around 300 calories and 11 grams of fat per serving.

Let's see how they did:

Daily Bread (Lasagna with Meat Sauce) Servings per bag: 1

This sample can be made in the bag for convenience.  All you do is add one cup of boiling water to the bag and then ziplock it closed and let it sit for 8-9 minutes, that is after you remove the oxygen absorber from the bag (hopefully you wouldn't forget to do that like I almost did).  I followed the instructions to the T (not very hard) and it may have actually sat in the bag a little longer than 9 minutes as I was waiting for the other sample.

Here's how it looked when I opened the bag.  

I'm not sure if you can see it or not but the sauce was very watery, you can see noodles and some meat and the tomatoes.

Here's how it looked on the plate (keep in mind I strained out the excess water and the white around it is from the other sample)

So it actually looks like it will taste good once it's out of the bag.  On the bag it says for convenience you can eat it straight from the bag.  So that's nice as well.

Upon tasting it though, it seemed really bland like it needed salt added to it.  The kids wouldn't eat more than one bite of it.  But then they don't like tomatoes or red sauce very well.  I wasn't a big fan of it but maybe I just needed to stir it more.  When my husband came home and tasted it, he said it was a little bland but that it was fine (keep in mind his sense of smell has always been partially blocked and therefore his tasting abilities are limited).  His serving had sat a little longer and was maybe mixed a little better than the serving we ate.

Wise Company (Pasta Alfredo) Servings per bag: 4

This sample needed a pot of boiling water (could not be cooked in the bag).  It required 4 cups of boiling water and then you added the contents of the bag, stirred it, covered it and let it sit for 12-15 minutes.    My husband was really skeptical that there was actually 4 servings worth of food in that small bag.  We were pleasantly surprised and even had leftovers!  It made a lot of pasta!

Here's what it looked like in the pot after 15 minutes:

Here's how it looked on the plate:

Upon tasting it, the sauce was really thick and my kids thought it was a cheese sauce (even though it was just alfredo).  Some of the kids had seconds.  They actually really liked this one.  I liked this one better myself.  The flavor was good, the noodles were soft and the sauce was thick.  Again my husband thought this was a little bland too but he liked it fine too (again take that for what you will).

My only complaint with this sample is that it was just noodles and sauce.  No meat, no vegetables.  But since I also have those options in my food storage already, I could easily add meat and/or vegetables to it.

So what's the verdict?  Before my husband tried the samples, I would definitely go with Wise Company.  It tasted better had a thicker sauce and the most important reason I would go with it, my kids liked it.  But after he tasted it, maybe Daily Bread just didn't get a fair shake...maybe...I'll have to do a follow up post.

After pricing both options, the Wise Company is actually quite a bit cheaper on the their packages than Daily Bread.  The difference is that the Wise Company only has so many options which is how they keep their costs low.  You don't get to make up your own packages, you get what is in them and that's it. On the other hand, Daily Bread has quite a lot of variety in their meals and you can mix and match the packages to your tastes.  So maybe we just don't order the Lasagna.

Now to be fair to Daily Bread, I emailed and asked for a sample of something different.  We received the lasagna sample about 2 years ago (which shouldn't matter since the food is supposed to last unopened for 25 years) and we got our Wise Company sample a week ago (I ordered it after I saw a commercial for it during General Conference).  But like I said that shouldn't matter since it has a shelf life of 25 years.  So after we get the 2nd sample, assuming they'll give us another one, maybe we'll like it better.

So what do you think?  Try it out for yourself and let me know if you receive different meals to try and what you think of them.  Here are the websites:

Daily Bread:  http://www.dailybread.com/

Wise Company:  http://wisefoodstorage.com/